My mum (now aged 91 years) lives in my house. I converted my teaching studio into a Wing 12 years ago, and she has her own front door and separate living and sleeping areas......but a shared inside staircase.
According to her - we live completely separately, in fact (in her words) she 'never sees me'.
In reality, I go in to her every morning before work. She checks what time I come home every evening, 'pops' in to my lounge, my kitchen, my bedroom looking for me most evenings, I often cook enough for her when I am cooking my son's meals etc etc.
She has no overheads or added expenses as she is living under my roof.
My sister lives 20 minutes away and phones my mother every night, but 'hasn't got time' to come and see her during the week. She does come every weekend for an hour or so, and sometimes takes her out.
My brother lives abroad and has no interraction with me, but phones my mother about once a week.
Neither sibling has ever checked on how I'm doing or offered to take mum away, or have her to stay with them.......I am not strictly a 'Carer' but I do so many things for my mum on a daily basis.
Don't get me wrong - this situation was not forced on me 12 years ago, but to be honest, I never thought that having my mother living in my house would cause me to have to make so many alterations and sacrifices in my life, and I never considered that my siblings would literally pull right back and leave me to it. In fact - neither of them contact me any more - all news etc is passed between us by my mother. I have tried to re-open the communication between us all, to no avail.
My son is now about to go to Australia to live, and unlikely to return very often, and my partner and I would like to travel more and spend more time together (we currently do not live together because of my mother) and to that end I have decided that I would like to move house, and to ask my sister to take on the responsibility of my mother.
It sounds quite callous as I write it all down, but my mother is a domineering, quietly controlling woman who is an expert in emotional blackmail.
Am I selfish to want to change my living situation without including my mother?
My partner and I are on the wrong side of 50, and I worry that our quality time together is being jeopardized.
I would be grateful for some outsider views.
Thanks in advance.
Sorry, been a bad week here😣
My 92 year old grandmother is also an expert at emotional blackmail. She guilt trips me all the time in the hopes that I'll forgo the gym, or my part time job or whatever I'm doing for fun that evening, which really isn't fair to me whatsoever. As someone who is introverted and needs alone time to keep sane, this is extremely exhausting for me- both mentally and physically. I work two jobs where I deal with people all day, then I come home to the ongoing ball of crisis that is Grandma. So it's safe to say that I desperately need that time to myself every day to function properly. I'm slowly learning to let things go, and let it go in one ear and out the other. It takes practice.
As caregivers, it is critical that we take care of ourselves. What good will we be to anyone if we overload ourselves to the point of illness or injury? Yes, you and your husband need to take time for yourselves. There's nothing selfish or callous about it at all. It's necessary. There is nothing wrong with outsourcing/allocating care.
You are only ONE person and can only do so much. One person cannot do it all. One person cannot be there 24/7. You need help or else you're going to burnout and end up in the hospital. Then where will you and your family be?
In reality, start looking at AL facilities...if you really intend to travel before its too late.
The facilities will allow mom to be there for a month, (I think). Maybe that wud solve the problem, (& make mom more thankful to return to your home again).
The OP has a wonderful opportinity for a trip to Australia & the Mother may be vulnerable if left home alone.
It's about getting the needs of BOTH the Mother & the OP met.
I wouldnt say you are travelling. They are going to say you are selfish. You are not! You are a normal person that wants their independence.
I would say you need a break from the stress. Youve done 12yrs and you are done. Lay it on the line with your siblings. That things are going to change and they need to step up. There will be huge backlash by all 3 no matter what the reason.
Tell them your living your life is not up for discussion. They will only try to tear you down. It is to make you feel guilty. Tell them they have no say in how you live your life. I would keep repeating that.
Here are the choices for mom. She can live with one of you, or an apartment, or assisted living etc. Id give it a deadline date or it will drag on and on forever.
I wouldnt say you want their help. That will sound like they have a choice to say no. They arent going to want to change a thing. Its working for all of them. Heck who wouldn't want to just make a few min phone call a week?
They are all going to be angry with you. Too bad. You can say its all working for them, but not you any more. You need a break and are entitled to one. Your not abandoning anyone. You need this change and it will happen. I think I would lead with burnout and not discuss the travel. They will turn it into you being selfish and abandoning mom. It will be used as a total guilt trip. That way they dont have to step up.
I would definitely have a time line for this change to happen. If you dont set one, they will find every excuse to not help. So If I were you, I would have backup plan. If they dont help, here is what will happen. She goes to this place(apartment etc). This is a done deal.
As for them not checking in with you, its because they dont want to get caught up in the problems of mom being under your care. They can just play dumb. Then they dont have to know. That is why the distance.
So get ready. I would tell mom first. Id also be prepared to sell the house. Because your family is going to be very resentful that you have a MIL suite, and arent using it for her. You could say your downsizing. That might soften the blow. They are going to find every excuse to put mom right back in there again. They are going to say the nursing home is too expensive, or she needs somewhere to go after a hospital stay. How can you not take her back? It is not being used. Your not traveling all the time. Your being selfish etc, etc. Because its easy on them to blame /guilt you. Just something to concider.
I had a friend who had a MIL suite. His entire extended family kept pushing off sick relatives on him to care for, bc he had that space. Even had neices saying they couldnt care for their dad (his divorced brother) after surgery. They were in their mid 20s. They can hire a nurse. His other family members said they were going to have brother delivered on doorstep after surgery. I told him to call social worker at hospital and put a stop to that. He did. It was one relative after another. I told him to say it was rented out. It was stressing him out. He'd get rid of one relative, and here comes another.
You have to make sure that room isn't an option, or they will be trying to put mom back in it every chance they get. You can tell them you have to rent it out for the income. Your broke. They dont have to know you are traveling. Personally I wouldnt tell them. Or you can say I needed a break. Your entitled to one. Or you will find mom back on your doorstep. And you will be starting all over again. It wont get better either. Good luck.
We always talk about how much time can our LOs have, well what about how much time do we have? Really! Go live your life...time slips through our fingers way to fast!! You are not being selfish!
We want parents to be taken care of but it gets really tough doing it alone. I’ve been caring for my mom in my house for 14 years. Gets exhausting, emotionally and physically. Know what I mean? She needs to decide what is best for her. Sounds like she is ready to move on. Mom will have to adjust as many others have.
You say that you cared for your mom for for three months, glad you were happy with your choice but she has cared for her mom for 12 years. That’s a huge difference!
Glad you are at peace with how it worked out for you and your mom. We all have individual needs and situations though.
I appreciate all points of view & I now do feel that the time is right for me to change direction in my life - I may well keep you posted as I continue...!
Thanks so much to all who made such an effort to respond to my post.
If Mum is depending on you for her living arrangements, then you get a say in them. If the balance has swayed, or about to, to meet all Mum's needs but at the expense of YOUR needs it's time for a new plan for sure - one that is good for BOTH of you. Do it now. So your Mum can settle into a new location & enjoy it.
12 years is a long time so if you feel you need to move slower that other people suggest, maybe consider this: tell Mum about the grandson's travel plans & your future trip to Australia. Tell her it won't be possible to stay home alone as your trip will many weeks long so she will need to stay in respite / assisted living. Do they have respite available where you live? If so, research & find one then tour it & book Mum in for a week or two stay. She will get used to staying there & fitting in with the care routines, the social life, the meals etc. It will be a good transition.
What is the current back up plan for Mum if you say, broke your leg?
And NO it is not an option keeping her at your house. Maybe a small apartment nearby that you all take turns checking on her? (If brother lives abroad, then he can hire a caregiver to come on the days that he is supposed to be providing care) Fair is fair!
Assisted living? Senior community?
It all starts with a meeting.
You deserve a life, too.
I took my dad to live closer to me in a 55+ apartment that has wonderful amenities, social activities, community breakfasts, etc. He chooses to sit alone in his apartment smoking cigarettes. I check on him every day, bring him meals, do his laundry, medication, and cleaning. His dementia is getting worse, and I recently found a nurse to come once a week to insist that he changes clothes. My brother lives 3 states away, but supports any decision I make. I told him I need to get someone in to make sure dad showers and changes clothes. Non negotiable.
Speak up and take care of yourself. I think the “absent siblings” often underestimate the daily commitment made by the “caregiving” sibling. Good luck 👍🏼
If you don't do this, you will be filled with resentment and regrets. Your partner has no doubt been very supportive over the years as you have cared for your Mother.
Now is the time for your sister to step up and assume her responsibilities in caring for her Mother too.
Be strong, but have a plan well thought out with an "end-date" in mind. BTW, the "other side of 50's" is still very young and filled with many wonderful opportunities.
What do you want to accomplish with your life?
How do you want to live your life?
What needs are not being met in your life?
What are the major frustrations of mom living in your place?
What types of care do you provide that you would rather "others" do?
What kinds of help is available to meet her needs and relieve your frustrations?
How much time and money would this cost?
What finances does mom have to meet these needs?
Once you have figured these out, get your family members - mom included - together for a family conference about mom's care.
Outline why the current situation needs to change.
Ask mom what her preferences are about the lifestyle she would prefer. Just because she "likes" her current situation does not mean you have to give up your life to continue the current course.
Share what you have found in the way of support, finances, etc. and ask family how they are willing to help. Together, come up with a plan that attempts to meet everybody's needs. Remember that they do not have to help (nor do you), but it is better is everybody agreed on what the "plan" will be.
But...only one ever asked how I was doing. No one else cared as long as I did everything for our Mom which I did. Not employed for almost 10 yrs to be with her but yet Noone asked about me or my husband. She’s 87 mobile, still has her mind so heavens cant be hard to care for!!!
After watching my my own health suffer, my marriage shrivel we decided it was time to leave. We’re in the process of selling our home and moving out of state. We had a so called family meeting and we let the other siblings know that they needed to step up to the plate. Mom is now living w my sister, 5 mi away but away and I’m busy enjoying life again. I was never a care taker, I was a care GIVER!!!
Dont be afraid to do the same w your sister. Let her take over and see some of the struggles you had. It won’t take long for her to see that you were truly a saint keeping your Mom a dozen years! I wish you well and be blessed but find some peace like I am and live again!!! 💕
My mom is currently in rehab (mild heart attack, maybe mild stroke, and some Alzheimer's), definitely narcissistic, and this has been the most relaxing time at home I've had since I had Mom move in 2 years ago. My only sibling/brother passed away 3 years ago. The plan for now is for Mom to return home (and hire some in-home help for her), but I feel certain somewhere down the line, it may be necessary for AL. I will be returning to my full-time job in a week, and between that and Mom living here, I've had no time for dating. And it is just as well, as Mom has made it clear she wants no one else living here, especially a man :)
But you have someone, and you need to feel free to enjoy that relationship. Never let anyone suggest that you are selfish. Wanting to do things without constantly being judged is not being selfish. And as far as someone else mentioned about Honoring Thy Father and Mother...... they obviously have not had the "pleasure" of having a narcissistic parent. A narcissistic parent only truly cares about his/her own wants, has no idea what empathy is and is surely not respectful to others. So the best way of honoring that parent would be to ensure they have their needs met, but it does NOT have to be in your home. Check out assisted living and just let it be known you can no longer continue to "do it all". Do not feel that you need to explain anything to anyone. Just remember that your needs and wants are important.... "we" want to have some golden years to enjoy, too!
Iinstead of dumping on sister, I would just move Mum into one above places, and your sister can check in on her to make sure she is alright.
Your situation sounds similar to mine. My daughter and I did 90% of the additional care my mother couldn’t provide for my stepfather ( Alzheimer’s ) for 7 years+, then my mother after his passing ( food, arranging cleaning, dr appointments etc) so it was about 10 years all told and my already poor health deteriorated until now I’m 90% housebound. My siblings popped in occasionally ie a couple hrs a month, all my sister “could stand “. (Narcissist mother and sister, irresponsible spoiled brother) so family meeting resulted in “aww, too bad , you handle it “🙄. So I found her independent living facility, handled her move(well sister came and bossed the movers for 2 hrs while my children, husband and I spent weeks to get her packed / unpacked etc all the wrong way of course according to mother and sister ). After the move, then sister and brother brought a roll off in and spent a morning and tossed most of her remaining property, which somehow is still my fault and I stole all her stuff( guessing they told her that or she just won’t blame then like always. )
long story longer, people are what they are and you can’t change them. When they are toxic, that isn’t going to change so you need to think of self preservation. You aren’t old enough to lay down and let them walk on you nor are you solely responsible.
Its true you should honor your parents but it’s also true parents are commanded not to exasperate their children and are responsible to care for them in a loving manner. You are supposed to be as peaceful with all people but the key to that scripture is AS FAR AS it depends upon you. You should be treated with love and dignity and you can not force that if it doesn’t exist in their vocabulary.
Run off into the sunset while you can, honey - you’ve done enough!