Follow
Share

Hubby makes non stop excuses "why" he "can't". Tried fun activities, walks in lovely surroundings, outings he's interested in... it's so discouraging and draining. He just needs to move

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
We did the same with my MIL, she stalled out of her progress no matter how we incentivized her. Right before needing AL she wouldn't even walk to the mailbox, or walk her dog a short distance. She went into AL due to short term memory impairment. Eventually she refused to get out of bed and now she's in LTC as a 2-person assist. But we think it had more to do with cognitive/memory issues and/or undiagnosed depression more than anything else be.

Has your husband had a memory/cognitive exam? Have you talked to his doctor about possible depression? Have you had a "come to Jesus" discussion about how much more likely it will be for him to stay in his home with you helping him if he can't help himself do things and move places? It doesn't seem rational of him, so there's something else going on.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
babsjvd May 2022
This was so my mom… she just flat out refused, decided she wasn’t walking to the dining room anymore.. I told her it would land her in a wheelchair, didn’t take long… I regret the fights….
(2)
Report
See 1 more reply
Have his doctor check him for depression. Depressed people lack motivation and have no drive. You won't be able to convince him. Save your efforts.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

hug! try reward/punishment.

"Dear, sweetest husband, if you walk together with me today a little, I'll give you your favorite snack/meal right after, plus 3 donuts."

"Dear, sweetest husband, if you don't walk with me today a little, you will be forced to watch your least favorite, most boring movie (with your least favorite actor) three times in a row, followed by Brussels Sprouts for breakfast, lunch and dinner all week, and you must pay me $200 for every day you don't walk. I'm not kidding."

----
a technique i use at home, with my LO:

when they come back from walking to the bathroom (with the walker), i force them to walk around the living room, before they're allowed to sit back down. they resist, but every time, i manage to persuade, and then they feel quite good about having walked some rounds. i also force them to drink water after.

another technique i used:
sometimes my LO listens more to the physio, than to family. so sometimes i hire the physio to force my LO to do exercises.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

In your profile you say he has been sedentary for decades.
This is not going to change, and your determination, after the recent SEVERAL MONTHS of rehab work, is going to merely frustrate you.
Nowhere do you mention your husbands age. It takes a good deal of determination, and simple love for movement, at some point. I cared as a nurse for 90 year olds who were not only determined to move, but who FEARED dreadfully any orders for bed rest for any number of days, warning doctors that this would mean they could not get back their strength and mobility.
A low dose anti depressant is worth a try. But several decades?? I would bet that and everything else has already been tried.
I would practice acceptance at this point. You already realize that long term this won't be good for hubby's health. But I doubt there is a lot you can try that hasn't been tried already and this is a source now of much frustration for both you and for your husband.
Best of luck out to you. DO try to get him up even for short amount of time. Don't fetch him his water, his glasses. Make him do the work. And do have an honest talk with him that you will not be able to continue in his care when his mobility is gone and he is bedbound.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Sorry to say this, but you might want to let it go. You can't change anyone but yourself.

As a certified personal trainer, I can tell you that if your husband doesn't want to move even moderately, there is nothing that you can do.

I've seen the same resistance in both personal and professional relationships and you're just beating your head against the wall.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I tried with my Daddy. He just couldn't. He walked from the chair to the bed. From the bed to the chair. From the chair to the bathroom. That was it. He didn't even get up to get snacks, coffee or water. He was unsteady and needed a walker. He used a cane but that impaired him in carrying anything. So, one day he fell, couldn't get up I couldn't get him up. Called 911. Ended up in hospital. He then went to rehab which led to a nursing facility which led to the hospital again and then a group home. Soon he was bed ridden and 30 days later he was gone. The whole process was 11 months but you need to choose - argue and get no where and frustrated, or just leave them alone and just let them make their choice. Been there, done that - got the t-shirt three times over. Prayers for you and yours.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

My mom is horrible with being mobile! The only time she moves is when the PT is here or the aide that I have hired to do her exercises with her (and other things due to her dementia). She has never been an active person and it has made her health very poor. She's a poster child for what NOT to do if you want to be healthy and pain free.

So, for your hubby. Hire someone to do exercises with him. Maybe he'll be like my mom and be VERY compliant with everyone but you. Maybe try going to an exercise class with him. Or doing a DVD together?

If he likes to go on outings, park far away and make him walk with you. Make him do things for himself around the house. Ask him to get you things. Make up things just to get him to move. Asking him to move for no reason is not working so you have to get creative and a little devious.

I am so close to giving up on my mom and her mobility. I know without her PT helpers she would be in a LOT more pain (which led us to our current round of therapists) and would hardly be able to move. I know she will end up in a wheelchair and then a nursing home if I give up on it. I can't do it with her anymore myself because of too many bad memories of the times that she whined and complained and would not do anything to help herself.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

You cannot care more than HE does about his health. Leave him alone to suffer the consequences of his own choices. Be sure to research Assisted Living Facilities and Skilled Nursing Facilities as well, should the need arise for DH to be placed in managed care. Let DH know about it, too. Actions do have consequences for ALL of us.

Keep on with your own activity level so you won't wind up with a bad health profile yourself. Be sure to get out and have some fun too, because you don't need to stay immobilized in the house 24/7 just because DH chooses to do so.

Best of luck to you
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
againx100 May 2022
I care way more than my mom does about her own health. It's always been that way. Now that she has dementia, I feel bad about giving up. But that's what I will HAVE to do at some point. And I will watch her decline and listen (barely) to her complain about all her aches and pains and then complain even more when she ends up in the hospital and then nursing home. Even before dementia, she did not see the connection between sitting and sitting and her poor mobility.

I have learned a lot of lessons on what NOT to do to be able to enjoy your golden years.
(2)
Report
See 1 more reply
Why do you think your going to change an 82 yr old after decades of not moving. I am surprised he was in therapy for months if he was just going to throw that all away. In your profile you say he has diabetes. I will assume he is told that without moving his circulation is less and the chance of getting gangrene is more. That means amputation. Bet he is overweight.

Some people have no motivation and are stubborn. I used to visit a elderly lady. She was the sweetest thing. She was 92 and suffered from water retention in her ankles. It was like all the water in her legs went to her ankles. They were huge. All she had to do was keep her feet up. But no, she wanted to sit in her favorite chair with her feet flat on the floor. Her daughter told me when she was in rehab doing therapy for a broken hip, the swelling disappeared because she was moving and keeping her feet up. Got home and ankles swelling again.

I think what we need to realize as people, that we cannot change people. You have to except this is how its going to be. Your DH has a right to live the way he wants. You are just stressing yourself out for someone who does not care. I don't think its depression, I think its years if being lazy. If he is capable of doing something make him do it. Do not disable him. I would tell him "I love you but I am not stressing out about your health anymore. And when your care gets more than I can do, you will go to a NH" I am not beyond a little threat. Lay it out for him and then no surprises when he needs NH care. My DH does not want to go to a NH. He can be stubborn and I have told him that I will care for him as long as I can but...her has to be cooperative.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Why would a man who's been sedentary for decades suddenly decide he enjoys walks in lovely surroundings? And fun activities are not fun if you're in pain.

If you'll forgive me, your approach sounds rather "all-or-nothing." His MD and PT want him to be more mobile, good. But he doesn't have to go on walks, he can just be encouraged to go to the further-away bathroom, or come to the kitchen to collect his sandwich, or as BoJ suggests do a circuit of the room before sitting down.

If he is physically able, merely reluctant to engage, would he respond better if he were in a group with other men? Does he have friends who might encourage him?

And if he won't get out of his chair, show him pictures of pressure sores. There are some really lurid ones out there on the internet. "Your if you don't get up," you tell him.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Start looking at nursing homes.

Simply tell him that you will not be able to provide care when he is 100% immobile, so he needs to decide which nursing home he wants to live in.

Don't nag him, after decades that has not worked, nor will it work now.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter